In the article by Sharon Gill, we begin to understand the Comprehension Matrix and how we can organize our activities into pre-reading, during reading, and post-reading.
Gill also writes about the three theories involved in comprehension: Schema, Transactional, Constructivist.
I believe that teachers can create an environment that works for all three of these theories.
Schema involves a readers use of prior knowledge to make sense of new information. Teachers could devise a lesson plan that surrounds some elemental part of the story they are reading.
For example, if students watch a video and paint a picture of a butterfly, then read a text about the migrating monarchs, their confusion will be less likely..while an interest increase will be more likely.
Transactional surrounds the idea that different experiences = different meaning. Readers will adopt either a efferent (Take away information) or aesthetic (Take away experiences).
A good example of this is what Halloween means to an American L1 student vs a Spanish L2 student. Latino culture typically do not celebrate Halloween so a teacher must make sure that this holiday is defined to the L2's and that their culture is also described to L1s.
A good way to sort out this theory is by asking; Why am I reading this. A pintrest user created a bookmark/checklist to promote this thought.
Constructivist theory uses the construction of their ow knowledge by making connections. Gill stated that reading, writing, drawing, graphic organizers, etc are a great because they help build and extend comprehension.

I love the why am I reading this poster! Very useful for students who don't know why they have to read something. Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteI really liked the graphic you included on Schema. I feel that it could be very helpful in explaining and relaying to students what this is exactly. I also thought the example you provided regarding the video and reading on butterflies is a great way to activate stronger comprehension.
ReplyDelete